nintendoes wrote:

excobar75 wrote:

MetalliCube wrote:

excobar75 wrote:

nintendoes wrote:

excobar75 wrote:frog suit for the wiiiiiinnnnnnnnn

The Hammer Bros. suit was cool too. . . but it was rare.

but i have to disagree with you mate...smb3 was good, but SMW was the best of all time....OF ALL TIME

I'm kinda on the fence about that one. I grew up playing both and they both pretty much gave me equal enjoyment. I'd say Super Mario World wins more in the graphics and polish department, but as an overall game if I HAD to choose, I think I gotta give the slight edge to Mario 3. It had more creative worlds, cooler powerups, and was a trickier than Mario World, which seemed to go a little softer on the difficulty. I definetly had more frusterating moments with Mario 3, but ultimately that just made the experience more rewarding when you finally overcame it. Giant/Ice/Sky world > Dinosaur World. I did love star and special world though.

not only that....i mean cmon 96 lvls with a shitload of secrets ....and all the different coloured yoshi's cmon its no competition...

Yeah, after all the secrets, I would say SMW was more challenging but as MC said SMB3 was just more creative and fresh feeling for it's time. SMB3 was an EXPLOSION of unique ideas.

i liked how you could finish that thing in 24 lvls..lol

and things like star road I remeber 1st finding it and being like WTF, what about the ghost houses man with the secret doors and shit..........

best smb ever

nintendoes wrote:

excobar75 wrote:

nintendoes wrote:

excobar75 wrote:

MetalliCube wrote:

excobar75 wrote:

nintendoes wrote:

excobar75 wrote:frog suit for the wiiiiiinnnnnnnnn

The Hammer Bros. suit was cool too. . . but it was rare.

but i have to disagree with you mate...smb3 was good, but SMW was the best of all time....OF ALL TIME

I'm kinda on the fence about that one. I grew up playing both and they both pretty much gave me equal enjoyment. I'd say Super Mario World wins more in the graphics and polish department, but as an overall game if I HAD to choose, I think I gotta give the slight edge to Mario 3. It had more creative worlds, cooler powerups, and was a trickier than Mario World, which seemed to go a little softer on the difficulty. I definetly had more frusterating moments with Mario 3, but ultimately that just made the experience more rewarding when you finally overcame it. Giant/Ice/Sky world > Dinosaur World. I did love star and special world though.

not only that....i mean cmon 96 lvls with a shitload of secrets ....and all the different coloured yoshi's cmon its no competition...

Yeah, after all the secrets, I would say SMW was more challenging but as MC said SMB3 was just more creative and fresh feeling for it's time. SMB3 was an EXPLOSION of unique ideas.

i liked how you could finish that thing in 24 lvls..loland things like star road I remeber 1st finding it and being like WTF, what about the ghost houses man with the secret doors and shit..........

best smb ever

Both games were great but SMB3 at that time was just too amazing.BTW- I LOVE GHOST HOUSES!!!

no doubt smb3 was good....lsmw was better and is still to this imo the best mario by a country mile...

excobar75 wrote:

nintendoes wrote:

excobar75 wrote:frog suit for the wiiiiiinnnnnnnnn

The Hammer Bros. suit was cool too. . . but it was rare.

but i have to disagree with you mate...smb3 was good, but SMW was the best of all time....OF ALL TIME

This

I will admit, this game looks pretty damn good.

It just better not end up like SPM.

nintendoes wrote:

MKDrifter wrote:I will admit, this game looks pretty damn good.It just better not end up like SPM.

Super Paper Mario was only good (as opposed to great) by the series standards. If it was a different title it would be labeled phenomenal.

I still think that removing the turn-based mechanic was stupid. As an RPG it would have been amazing.