Game Console Report Card -- Fall 2007 edition (page 2 of 6)
- August 14, 2007 14:53 PM PST
- Email this!
TABLE OF CONTENTS
PlayStation 3
- Games: C+
- Price: C-
- Online Play: B-
- Graphics: A
- Innovation: C+
- Hardware Design: A+
- Extras: A
- Overall: C
Comments: We can't help but feel disappointed with the PS3's first year results as a gaming machine. If it wasn't for the system's high-value Blu-ray movie compatibility and free online play, the PS3 would likely have received an "F" in Price for its almost-out-of-reach asking price. Just before E3 2007, Sony announced a desperately needed $100 price adjustment; though this adjustment is certainly helpful, it's a stopgap solution at best. What Sony really needs is a console priced below $500, even if it's some sort of stripped down "Gamer's Edition".
The quantity and quality of currently available games causes some concern, though that situation will sharply improve this fall with the introduction of triple-A titles such as Heavenly Sword, Uncharted, and Ratchet & Clank Future. Early 2008 will bring Metal Gear Solid, a system-defining game whose exclusivity Sony must protect at all costs. But signing future PS3-exclusive titles remains a challenge for Sony in the short term. The PS3 faces a circular problem: it needs great exclusive third-party games, but third parties are sticking with multi-platform games because the Xbox 360 has a higher install base. Another price drop would greatly improve the PS3's situation by moving more units into homes. Sony is advised to take it lumps and drop the PS3 to $450, even if the console must lose a feature or two in the process.
That said, there is much to admire about the PS3. Its hardware design is virtually flawless, and a far cry from the Xbox 360's rather slapped-together look and feel. Its Cross Media Bar interface is sleek and effective, though we'd like to see in implemented in-game. The PS3 also excels in the areas of graphics and high-tech extras, though much of its technology is unproven. We don't yet know whether Blu-ray support and the much-hyped Cell processor will be key advantages for Sony or merely serve to jack up the price. Similarly, the Sixaxis controller is good but uneven; it performs well, but the motion sensing is a poor replacement for its past rumble functions. A rumble upgrade would be welcome, but frankly, Sony has bigger problems to worry about.
Overall, the PS3 must apply itself more if it is to catch up to the Xbox 360 and Wii. The system desperately needs better games, and more of them. A lower price will also be crucial. Lately, Sony has allowed hollow technological achievements to overshadow other, more fundamental considerations. This approach will not succeed with the PlayStation 3.
